Why Do Employees Work Hard — And Why Do They Stop?
Imagine two employees joining the same organisation on the same day.
Both have similar qualifications. Both receive identical salaries. Both work under the same supervisor.
Six months later, one is thriving—taking initiative, staying late when needed, offering ideas, volunteering for responsibility. The other has begun to do the minimum required. Emails are answered slowly. Deadlines are met, but without care. Creativity has disappeared.
What happened?
The difference is not intelligence. It is not skill. It is motivation.
Understanding why people work hard—and why they gradually reduce effort—is the central question of organisational psychology. It is also one of the most misunderstood.
Work Is Not Just a Task — It Is a Psychological Experience
Students often assume motivation is about rewards: pay, bonuses, promotions. These matter. But they are rarely enough.
Work is a psychological space where three powerful forces operate:
Identity – “Who am I here?”
Competence – “Am I capable?”
Meaning – “Does what I do matter?”
When work strengthens these three experiences, motivation rises naturally. When work threatens them, motivation declines—even if salary remains unchanged.
Why Employees Work Hard
1. Because Their Work Feels Meaningful
People are willing to invest extraordinary effort when they believe their work matters.
Consider hospital cleaning staff in a large medical centre. In one study, researchers discovered something surprising. Some cleaners described their job as “just mopping floors.” Others described it as “helping patients heal.” The second group took more initiative, helped patients’ families navigate hallways, and reported greater job satisfaction—despite having identical job descriptions.
The difference was meaning.
When employees can see the impact of their work, motivation becomes internal. They are no longer working only for pay—they are working for purpose.
As future organisational psychologists, you must always ask:
Does the employee see the significance of their role?
2. Because They Believe Effort Will Be Rewarded
Motivation is not blind enthusiasm. It is calculated energy.
Employees constantly (often unconsciously) evaluate three questions:
If I try harder, will I perform better?
If I perform better, will I be recognised?
Is that recognition important to me?
If the answer to any one of these is “no,” effort drops.
For example, in organisations where promotions are based on favoritism rather than performance, high performers eventually reduce effort. Not because they are lazy—but because the system teaches them that effort is irrelevant.
Fair and transparent systems protect motivation.
3. Because They Feel Treated Fairly
Fairness is one of the most powerful motivational forces in organisational life.
Employees compare themselves constantly:
“I work more hours than she does.”
“My appraisal was harsher.”
“His salary is higher for the same role.”
When employees perceive injustice, they attempt to restore balance psychologically. They may reduce effort, emotionally withdraw, or leave.
Importantly, fairness is not only about salary. It includes:
Fair procedures
Clear criteria
Respectful communication
Even a negative decision can preserve motivation if the process feels just and dignified.
4. Because Goals Are Clear
Ambiguity kills motivation.
Imagine being told, “Improve performance.” Improve what? By how much? By when?
Clear goals focus attention. Specific targets create direction. Challenging yet achievable goals stimulate energy.
When employees know exactly what is expected, motivation gains structure.
When expectations are unclear, effort becomes scattered and inconsistent.
Why Employees Reduce Effort
Now we turn to a more uncomfortable question: why do motivated employees lose drive?
Motivation rarely disappears overnight. It erodes gradually.
1. When Effort Feels Futile
If employees repeatedly experience situations where hard work does not change outcomes, they may develop a sense of futility.
This resembles what psychology calls learned helplessness.
Over time, the internal dialogue shifts:
“Why try?”
“Nothing changes anyway.”
“It doesn’t matter.”
In such environments, even highly capable individuals disengage.
2. When Work Overwhelms Resources
High demand with low support leads to burnout.
Burnout is not simply fatigue. It has three components:
Emotional exhaustion
Cynicism or detachment
Reduced sense of accomplishment
During the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare professionals reported strong commitment to patients but declining energy. Motivation was not absent; it was depleted.
Organisations must remember: motivation requires recovery. Without rest and support, effort cannot sustain itself.
3. When Psychological Safety Is Absent
Employees will not invest energy in environments where mistakes are punished harshly or ideas are ridiculed.
In psychologically unsafe workplaces:
Employees avoid initiative.
Innovation declines.
Risk-taking disappears.
Silence replaces engagement.
Motivation thrives where individuals feel safe to contribute without fear of humiliation.
Psychological Withdrawal: The Quiet Exit
Perhaps the most dangerous form of reduced motivation is psychological withdrawal.
The employee is present—but not engaged.
Tasks are completed mechanically. Creativity vanishes. Emotional connection fades.
Research by Gallup consistently shows that a large percentage of employees worldwide are “not engaged.” This is not active rebellion—it is quiet detachment.
Psychological withdrawal often happens when:
Effort is not recognised.
Growth opportunities disappear.
Meaning fades.
Trust breaks down.
It is the organisational equivalent of emotional distancing in relationships.
A Real Case: Cultural Shift at Microsoft
Before 2014, Microsoft was known for intense internal competition. Performance ranking systems forced managers to label employees relative to each other.
Collaboration suffered. Employees guarded information.
When Satya Nadella became CEO, he shifted the culture toward learning and growth mindset principles. The emphasis moved from “proving yourself” to “improving yourself.”
The result?
Increased collaboration
Renewed innovation
Rising employee engagement
Motivation improved not because salaries changed dramatically, but because psychological conditions changed.
Motivation Is Systemic, Not Personal
Students often ask: “Is motivation a personality trait?”
The answer is no—and yes.
Individual differences matter. But organisational systems amplify or suppress those differences.
A motivated person placed in a toxic, unfair, ambiguous system will eventually disengage.
An average performer placed in a supportive, meaningful, fair system may flourish.
Motivation is not only inside the individual. It is created between the individual and the organisation.
Key Insight for Organisational Psychology Students
When analysing motivation in any workplace, ask these five diagnostic questions:
Does the employee find meaning in their work?
Is the effort–reward relationship clear?
Are procedures and treatment fair?
Are goals specific and achievable?
Are demands balanced with resources?
These questions move us beyond blaming individuals toward understanding systems.
Closing Reflection
Employees rarely wake up deciding to be disengaged.
Motivation declines when psychological needs are unmet, when fairness disappears, when clarity dissolves, or when exhaustion overwhelms meaning.
Understanding this truth transforms how organisations manage people.
Motivation is not about pushing harder.
It is about designing conditions where effort becomes natural.
Posts
.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment